MEDICAL AND MENTAL DISCLAIMER: This site and the views expressed by Wayne McDonald are not providing health care, mental health care, medical or nutrition therapy services or attempting to diagnose, treat, prevent or cure in any manner whatsoever any physical ailment, or any mental or emotional issue, disease or condition. Read the complete Medical and Mental Disclaimer.
DETAILS ABOUT MENTAL EQUIVALENTS
Mental Equivalents are the inner thoughts, beliefs, and vivid mental images that create a person’s outer reality. To follow are a few examples.
Mental Equivalent: The Science of Mind
In the Science of Mind philosophy, developed by Ernest Holmes, the “mental equivalent of disease” refers to the core concept that every physical ailment, condition, or circumstance has a corresponding, invisible thought pattern or belief in the subjective mind.
It means that disease is not an external, independent force, but rather a manifestation of a “false mental state”—a belief, fear, or habitual thought pattern that has been allowed to take root in the individual’s consciousness.
Here is a breakdown of the meaning:
- The Law of Cause and Effect: The philosophy teaches that “for every visible form there is an invisible counterpart”. Therefore, before a disease appears in the body, it must first exist in the mind as a “mental equivalent”.
- Mental vs. Material: Disease is considered “mental, not material” because the body cannot get sick on its own; it is operated by intelligence.
- Not Always Conscious: The mental equivalent does not have to be a thought the person is actively thinking, but can exist in the subjective (subconscious) mind.
- Healing through Treatment: Healing occurs by changing the mental equivalent (belief) rather than just treating the body. This is done through “spiritual mind treatment” (affirmative prayer), which removes the mental equivalent of discord and replaces it with the “mental equivalent of health,” peace, and perfection.
Mental Equivalent: Holistic Health
In a holistic framework, the mental equivalent of disease is often understood as dis-ease—a profound state of imbalance, disharmony, or lack of ease across the interconnected layers of mind, body, and spirit.
Mental Equivalent: New Thought Teachings
In New Thought philosophy, the “mental equivalent of disease” refers to the belief that every physical ailment, sickness, or unhappy circumstance is the direct outward manifestation of a corresponding negative, fearful, or incorrect thought pattern held in the mind.
Rooted in the teachings of Phineas P. Quimby in the 1830s, this concept suggests that disease is not an external attacker (like germs) but an internal “false belief” or “error thought” that has been allowed to take shape in the physical body.
Key Aspects of the Concept
- Thoughts Shape Reality: New Thought holds that ideas and consciousness create the material world. Therefore, “right thinking” or “truth” produces health, while “wrong thinking” (fear, anger, worry, jealousy) creates disease.
- Disease as “Error”: Sickness is seen as a “mental error” or a “lie” that seems true to those who believe it, such as in the case of contagious diseases.
- Healing through Correction: Because the cause is mental, healing is accomplished by changing the belief, not merely treating the body. By replacing erroneous thoughts with spiritual truths (such as “I am one with Divine Mind/God”), the corresponding sickness is dissolved.
Core Beliefs and Origins
- Phineas P. Quimby: As the founder, Quimby often said, “If I believe I am sick, I am sick, for my feelings are my sickness, and my sickness is my belief in my mind”.
- Divine Oneness: Adherents often believe that because humans are inherently divine (one with God/Infinite Intelligence), they cannot be truly sick, as God cannot be sick. Sickness is merely a failure to realize this truth.
Common Examples in Teachings
- Fear: Considered a primary cause of physical illness (or a “faith” that things will go wrong).
- Anger/Resentment: Thought to be the mental equivalent of inflammation or irritation.
- Poverty Thought: The “mental equivalent” of lack or financial struggle.
This perspective fundamentally shifted the focus from medical or physical remedies to mental and spiritual methods of healing.
Mental Equivalent: Louise Hayes
Louise Hay’s “mental equivalent of disease” [or mental patterns] means that physical illnesses stem from specific, deep-seated, and negative mental thought patterns, emotional, or spiritual imbalances. She believed that “dis-ease” (lack of ease) starts in the mind—rooted in resentment, criticism, guilt, or fear—which eventually manifests as physical sickness.
Key Aspects of Louise Hay’s Philosophy:
Role of Emotions: Negative thoughts like fear cause “narrowness” or tension, while anger and resentment can manifest as cancer or aches.
Mind-Body Connection: Hay, a pioneer in self-help and author of You Can Heal Your Life, argued that changing thought patterns via affirmations can reverse illness.
Body as Messenger: She believed physical symptoms are signals from the body indicating a need to change mental habits, not just treat symptoms.
